Whitaker Chalk attorneys play an active role both in and out of the courtroom. Check out our latest news below or search for past articles by attorney, practice area or keyword.

Keep up to date with all of our Whitaker Chalk news. Sign up today.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Rocky Schwartz and Tom Harkins Achieve Defense Verdict in a Major Computer Software Copyright Infringement Case

In a case lasting well over 3 years ( filed August 31, 2007), Rocky Schwartz, as assisted by Tom Harkins, successfully achieved a defense verdict in a major computer software copyright infringement case brought by Gillani Consulting, Inc. against Ferguson Enterprises, Inc. Gillani sued Ferguson after Ferguson had acquired the assets of Full Service Supply (FSS), a Kennametal company. This Ferguson acquisition included, inter alia, FSS’s computer software, including Gillani’s claimed “Endura” copyrighted software. While Kennametal’s use was licensed, Gillani claimed that Ferguson’s use was unlicensed and thus infringing. During the course of the case, Gillani asserted that in excess of 60 separate copyright registrations were infringed. Gillani claimed damages ranging from $7M to in excess of $100M. In a series of summary judgment orders, Judge Reed O’Connor, USDC ND TX, dismissed all of Gillani’s copyright claims and found Ferguson to be the “prevailing party.” Judge O’Connor, by Orders dated March 22, 2011 and April 21, 2011, awarded Ferguson its attorney’s fees, out of pocket expenses and taxable costs of in excess of $1.55M.

  • Whitaker Chalk Swindle & Schwartz has been included in the 2022 "Best Law Firms" listed by U.S. News Best Lawyers©

  • Trusted counsel. Proven results since 1978.

  • Whitaker Chalk Means Business ®

  • Fort Worth Magazine named John Allen Chalk & Hunter McLean to the 2021 "The 400 most Influential" List

  • "Best Lawyers" Names 8 Whitaker Chalk Attorneys to the 2022 list

  • Higher Standards. Higher Expectations